PRoblem by Alan Nourse (1956)
The
letter came down the slot too early that morning to be the regular mail
run. Pete Greenwood eyed the New Philly photocancel with a dreadful
premonition. The letter said:
PETER:
Can you come East chop-chop, urgent? Grdznth problem getting to be a
PRoblem, need expert icebox salesman to get gators out of hair fast.
Yes? Math boys hot on this, citizens not so hot. Please come. TOMMY
Pete
tossed the letter down the gulper with a sigh. He had lost a bet to
himself because it had come three days later than he expected, but it
had come all the same, just as it always did when Tommy Heinz got
himself into a hole.
Not
that he didn't like Tommy. Tommy was a good PR-man, as PR-men go. He
just didn't know his own depth. PRoblem in a beady Grdznth eye! What
Tommy needed right now was a Bazooka Battalion, not a PR-man. Pete
settled back in the Eastbound Rocketjet with a sigh of resignation.
He
was just dozing off when the fat lady up the aisle let out a scream. A
huge reptilian head had materialized out of nowhere and was hanging in
air, peering about uncertainly. A scaly green body followed, four feet
away, complete with long razor talons, heavy hind legs, and a whiplash
tail with a needle at the end. For a moment the creature floated upside
down, legs thrashing. Then the head and body joined, executed a
horizontal pirouette, and settled gently to the floor like an eight-foot
circus balloon.
Two
rows down a small boy let out a muffled howl and tried to bury himself
in his mother's coat collar. An indignant wail arose from the fat lady.
Someone behind Pete groaned aloud and quickly retired behind a
newspaper.
The
creature coughed apologetically. "Terribly sorry," he said in a coarse
rumble. "So difficult to control, you know. Terribly sorry… ." His voice
trailed off as he lumbered down the aisle toward the empty seat next to
Pete.
The
fat lady gasped, and an angry murmur ran up and down the cabin. "Sit
down," Pete said to the creature. "Relax. Cheerful reception these days,
eh?"
"You don't mind?" said the creature.
"Not
at all." Pete tossed his briefcase on the floor. At a distance the huge
beast had looked like a nightmare combination of large alligator and
small tyrannosaurus. Now, at close range Pete could see that the
"scales" were actually tiny wrinkles of satiny green fur. He knew, of
course, that the Grdznth were mammals—"docile, peace-loving mammals,"
Tommy's PR-blasts had declared emphatically—but with one of them sitting
about a foot away Pete had to fight down a wave of horror and
revulsion.
The
creature was most incredibly ugly. Great yellow pouches hung down below
flat reptilian eyes, and a double row of long curved teeth glittered
sharply. In spite of himself Pete gripped the seat as the Grdznth
breathed at him wetly through damp nostrils.
The Grdznth nodded sadly. "It's horrible of me, but I just can't help it. I
always
misgauge. Last time it was the chancel of St. John's
Cathedral. I nearly stampeded morning prayer—" He paused to catch his
breath. "What an effort. The energy barrier, you know. Frightfully hard
to make the jump." He broke off sharply, staring out the window. "Dear
me! Are we going
east?"
"Oh, dear. I wanted
Florida."
"Well, you seem to have drifted through into the wrong airplane," said Pete. "Why Florida?"
The
Grdznth looked at him reproachfully. "The Wives, of course. The climate
is so much better, and they mustn't be disturbed, you know."
"Of course," said Pete. "In their condition. I'd forgotten."
"And I'm told that things have been somewhat unpleasant in the East just now," said the Grdznth.
Pete
thought of Tommy, red-faced and frantic, beating off hordes of
indignant citizens. "So I hear," he said. "How many more of you are
coming through?"
"Oh,
not many, not many at all. Only the Wives—half a million or so—and
their spouses, of course." The creature clicked his talons nervously.
"We haven't much more time, you know. Only a few more weeks, a few
months at the most. If we couldn't have stopped over here, I just don't
know
what
we'd have done."
"Think nothing of it," said Pete indulgently. "It's been great having you."
The
passengers within earshot stiffened, glaring at Pete. The fat lady was
whispering indignantly to her seat companion. Junior had half emerged
from his mother's collar; he was busy sticking out his tongue at the
Grdznth.
The creature shifted uneasily. "Really, I think—perhaps Florida would be better."
"Going to try it again right now? Don't rush off," said Pete.
"Oh, I don't mean to rush. It's been lovely, but—" Already the Grdznth was beginning to fade out.
"Try four miles down and a thousand miles southeast," said Pete.
The
creature gave him a toothy smile, nodded once, and grew more
indistinct. In another five seconds the seat was quite empty. Pete
leaned back, grinning to himself as the angry rumble rose around him
like a wave. He was a Public Relations man to the core—but right now he
was off duty. He chuckled to himself, and the passengers avoided him
like the plague all the way to New Philly.
But
as he walked down the gangway to hail a cab, he wasn't smiling so much.
He was wondering just how high Tommy was hanging him, this time.
The
lobby of the Public Relations Bureau was swarming like an upturned
anthill when Pete disembarked from the taxi. He could almost smell the
desperate tension of the place. He fought his way past scurrying clerks
and preoccupied poll-takers toward the executive elevators in the rear.
On
the newly finished seventeenth floor, he found Tommy Heinz pacing the
corridor like an expectant young father. Tommy had lost weight since
Pete had last seen him. His ruddy face was paler, his hair thin and
ragged as though chunks had been torn out from time to time. He saw Pete
step off the elevator, and ran forward with open arms. "I thought you'd
never get here!" he groaned. "When you didn't call, I was afraid you'd
let me down."
"Me?" said Pete. "I'd never let down a pal."
The
sarcasm didn't dent Tommy. He led Pete through the ante-room into the
plush director's office, bouncing about excitedly, his words tumbling
out like a waterfall. He looked as though one gentle shove might send
him yodeling down Market Street in his underdrawers. "Hold it," said
Pete. "Relax, I'm not going to leave for a while yet. Your girl screamed
something about a senator as we came in. Did you hear her?"
Tommy gave a violent start. "Senator! Oh, dear." He flipped a desk switch. "What senator is that?"
"Senator Stokes," the girl said wearily. "He had an appointment. He's ready to have you fired."
"All I need now is a senator," Tommy said. "What does he want?"
"Oh. That's what I was afraid of. Can you keep him there?"
"Don't
worry about that," said the girl. "He's growing roots. They swept
around him last night, and dusted him off this morning. His appointment
was for
yesterday, remember?"
"Remember!
Of course I remember. Senator Stokes—something about a riot in Boston."
He started to flip the switch, then added, "See if you can get Charlie
down here with his giz."
He
turned back to Pete with a frantic light in his eye. "Good old Pete.
Just in time. Just. Eleventh-hour reprieve. Have a drink, have a
cigar—do you want my job? It's yours. Just speak up."
"I fail to see," said Pete, "just why you had to drag me all the way from L.A. to have a cigar. I've got work to do."
"Selling movies, right?" said Tommy.
"To people who don't want to buy them, right?"
"In a manner of speaking," said Pete testily.
"Exactly,"
said Tommy. "Considering some of the movies you've been selling, you
should be able to sell anything to anybody, any time, at any price."
"Please. Movies are getting Better by the Day."
"Yes,
I know. And the Grdznth are getting worse by the hour. They're coming
through in battalions—a thousand a day! The more Grdznth come through,
the more they act as though they own the place. Not nasty or
anything—it's that infernal politeness that people hate most, I think.
Can't get them mad, can't get them into a fight, but they do anything
they please, and go anywhere they please, and if the people don't like
it, the Grdznth just go right ahead anyway."
Pete pulled at his lip. "Any violence?"
Tommy
gave him a long look. "So far we've kept it out of the papers, but
there have been some incidents. Didn't hurt the Grdznth a bit—they have
personal protective force fields around them, a little point they didn't
bother to tell us about. Anybody who tries anything fancy gets thrown
like a bolt of lightning hit him. Rumors are getting wild—people saying
they can't be killed, that they're just moving in to stay."
Pete nodded slowly. "Are they?"
"I
wish I knew. I mean, for sure. The psych-docs say no. The Grdznth
agreed to leave at a specified time, and something in their cultural
background makes them stick strictly to their agreements. But that's
just what the psych-docs think, and they've been known to be wrong."
"And the appointed time?"
Tommy
spread his hands helplessly. "If we knew, you'd still be in L.A.
Roughly six months and four days, plus or minus a month for the time
differential. That's strictly tentative, according to the math boys.
It's a parallel universe, one of several thousand already explored,
according to the Grdznth scientists working with Charlie Karns. Most of
the parallels are analogous, and we happen to be analogous to the
Grdznth, a point we've omitted from our PR-blasts. They have an
eight-planet system around a hot sun, and it's going to get lots hotter
any day now."
Pete's eyes widened. "Nova?"
"Apparently.
Nobody knows how they predicted it, but they did. Spotted it coming
several years ago, so they've been romping through parallel after
parallel trying to find one they can migrate to. They found one, sort of
a desperation choice. It's cold and arid and full of impassable
mountain chains. With an uphill fight they can make it support a
fraction of their population."
Tommy
shook his head helplessly. "They picked a very sensible system for
getting a good strong Grdznth population on the new parallel as fast as
possible. The males were picked for brains, education, ability and
adaptability; the females were chosen largely according to how pregnant
they were."
Pete grinned. "Grdznth in utero. There's something poetic about it."
"Just
one hitch," said Tommy. "The girls can't gestate in that climate, at
least not until they've been there long enough to get their glands
adjusted. Seems we have just the right climate here for gestating
Grdznth, even better than at home. So they came begging for permission
to stop here, on the way through, to rest and parturiate."
"So
Earth becomes a glorified incubator." Pete got to his feet
thoughtfully. "This is all very touching," he said, "but it just doesn't
wash. If the Grdznth are so unpopular with the masses, why did we let
them in here in the first place?" He looked narrowly at Tommy. "To be
very blunt, what's the parking fee?"
"Plenty,"
said Tommy heavily. "That's the trouble, you see. The fee is so high,
Earth just can't afford to lose it. Charlie Karns'll tell you why."
Charlie
Karns from Math Section was an intense skeleton of a man with a long
jaw and a long white coat drooping over his shoulders like a shroud. In
his arms he clutched a small black box.
"It's
the parallel universe business, of course," he said to Pete, with Tommy
beaming over his shoulder. "The Grdznth can cross through. They've been
able to do it for a long time. According to our figuring, this must
involve complete control of mass, space and dimension, all three. And
time comes into one of the three—we aren't sure which."
The
mathematician set the black box on the desk top and released the lid.
Like a jack-in-the-box, two small white plastic spheres popped out and
began chasing each other about in the air six inches above the box.
Presently a third sphere rose up from the box and joined the fun.
Pete watched it with his jaw sagging until his head began to spin. "No wires?"
"Strictly
no wires," said Charlie glumly. "No nothing." He closed the
box with a click. "This is one of their children's toys, and
theoretically, it can't work. Among other things, it takes null-gravity
to operate."
Pete sat down, rubbing his chin. "Yes," he said. "I'm beginning to see. They're teaching you this?"
Tommy
said, "They're trying to. He's been working for weeks with their top
mathematicians, him and a dozen others. How many computers have you
burned out, Charlie?"
"Four.
There's a differential factor, and we can't spot it. They have the
equations, all right. It's a matter of translating them into constants
that make sense. But we haven't cracked the differential."
"And if you do, then what?"
Charlie
took a deep breath. "We'll have inter-dimensional control, a practical,
utilizable transmatter. We'll have null-gravity, which means the
greatest advance in power utilization since fire was discovered. It
might give us the opening to a concept of time travel that makes some
kind of sense. And power! If there's an energy differential of any
magnitude—" He shook his head sadly.
"We'll also know the time-differential," said Tommy hopefully, "and how long the Grdznth gestation period will be."
"It's
a fair exchange," said Charlie. "We keep them until the girls have
their babies. They teach us the ABC's of space, mass and dimension."
Pete nodded. "That is, if you can make the people put up with them for another six months or so."
Tommy sighed. "In a word—yes. So far we've gotten nowhere at a thousand miles an hour."
"I
can't do it!" the cosmetician wailed, hurling himself down on a chair
and burying his face in his hands. "I've failed. Failed!"
The Grdznth sitting on the stool looked regretfully from the cosmetician to the Public Relations men. "I say—I
am
sorry… ." His coarse voice trailed off as he peeled a long strip of cake makeup off his satiny green face.
Pete Greenwood stared at the cosmetician sobbing in the chair. "What's eating
him?"
"Professional
pride," said Tommy. "He can take twenty years off the face of any woman
in Hollywood. But he's not getting to first base with Gorgeous over
there. This is only one thing we've tried," he added as they moved on
down the corridor. "You should see the field reports. We've tried
selling the advances Earth will have, the wealth, the power. No dice.
The man on the street reads our PR-blasts, and then looks up to see one
of the nasty things staring over his shoulder at the newspaper."
"So you can't make them beautiful," said Pete. "Can't you make them cute?"
"With those teeth? Those eyes? Ugh."
"How about the 'jolly company' approach?"
"Tried
it. There's nothing jolly about them. They pop out of nowhere,
anywhere. In church, in bedrooms, in rush-hour traffic through Lincoln
Tunnel—look!"
Pete
peered out the window at the traffic jam below. Cars were snarled up
for blocks on either side of the intersection. A squad of traffic cops
were converging angrily on the center of the mess, where a stream of
green reptilian figures seemed to be popping out of the street and
lumbering through the jammed autos like General Sherman tanks.
"Ulcers," said Tommy. "City traffic isn't enough of a mess as it is. And they don't
do
anything about it. They apologize profusely, but they keep
coming through." The two started on for the office. "Things are getting
to the breaking point. The people are wearing thin from sheer
annoyance—to say nothing of the nightmares the kids are having, and the
trouble with women fainting."
The
signal light on Tommy's desk was flashing scarlet. He dropped into a
chair with a sigh and flipped a switch. "Okay, what is it now?"
"Just
another senator," said a furious male voice. "Mr. Heinz, my arthritis
is beginning to win this fight. Are you going to see me now, or aren't
you?"
"Yes, yes, come right in!" Tommy turned white. "Senator Stokes," he muttered. "I'd completely forgotten—"
The
senator didn't seem to like being forgotten. He walked into the office,
looked disdainfully at the PR-men, and sank to the edge of a chair,
leaning on his umbrella.
"You
have just lost your job," he said to Tommy, with an icy edge to his
voice. "You may not have heard about it yet, but you can take my word
for it. I personally will be delighted to make the necessary
arrangements, but I doubt if I'll need to. There are at least a hundred
senators in Washington who are ready to press for your dismissal, Mr.
Heinz—and there's been some off-the-record talk about a lynching.
Nothing official, of course."
"Senator be hanged! We want somebody in this office who can manage to
do
something."
"Do something! You think I'm a magician? I can just make them vanish? What do you want me to do?"
The senator raised his eyebrows. "You needn't shout, Mr. Heinz. I'm not the least interested in
what
you do. My interest is focused completely on a collection
of five thousand letters, telegrams, and visiphone calls I've received
in the past three days alone. My constituents, Mr. Heinz, are making
themselves clear. If the Grdznth do not go, I go."
"That would never do, of course," murmured Pete.
The senator gave Pete a cold, clinical look. "Who is this person?" he asked Tommy.
"An assistant on the job," Tommy said quickly. "A very excellent PR-man."
The senator sniffed audibly. "Full of ideas, no doubt."
"Brimming," said Pete. "Enough ideas to get your constituents off your neck for a while, at least."
"Indeed," said Pete. "Tommy, how fast can you get a PR-blast to penetrate? How much medium do you control?"
"And how fast can you sample response and analyze it?"
"We can have prelims six hours after the PR-blast. Pete, if you have an idea, tell us!"
Pete
stood up, facing the senator. "Everything else has been tried, but it
seems to me one important factor has been missed. One that will take
your constituents by the ears." He looked at Tommy pityingly. "You've
tried to make them lovable, but they aren't lovable. They aren't even
passably attractive. There's one thing they
are
though, at least half of them."
Tommy's jaw sagged. "Pregnant," he said.
"Now see here," said the senator. "If you're trying to make a fool out of me to my face—"
"Sit
down and shut up," said Pete. "If there's one thing the man in the
street reveres, my friend, it's motherhood. We've got several hundred
thousand pregnant Grdznth just waiting for all the little Grdznth to
arrive, and nobody's given them a side glance." He turned to Tommy. "Get
some copywriters down here. Get a Grdznth obstetrician or two. We're
going to put together a PR-blast that will twang the people's
heart-strings like a billion harps."
The
color was back in Tommy's cheeks, and the senator was forgotten as a
dozen intercom switches began snapping. "We'll need TV hookups, and
plenty of newscast space," he said eagerly. "Maybe a few photographs—do
you suppose maybe
baby
Grdznth are lovable?"
"They
probably look like salamanders," said Pete. "But tell the people
anything you want. If we're going to get across the sanctity of Grdznth
motherhood, my friend, anything goes."
"It's genius," chortled Tommy. "Sheer genius."
"If it sells," the senator added, dubiously.
"It'll sell," Pete said. "The question is: for how long?"
The
planning revealed the mark of genius. Nothing sudden, harsh, or
crude—but slowly, in a radio comment here or a newspaper story there,
the emphasis began to shift from Grdznth in general to Grdznth as
mothers. A Rutgers professor found his TV discussion on "Motherhood as
an Experience" suddenly shifted from 6:30 Monday evening to 10:30
Saturday night. Copy rolled by the ream from Tommy's office, refined
copy, hypersensitively edited copy, finding its way into the light of
day through devious channels.
Three days later a Grdznth miscarriage threatened, and was averted. It was only a page 4 item, but it was a beginning.
Determined
movements to expel the Grdznth faltered, trembled with indecision. The
Grdznth were ugly, they frightened little children, they
were
a trifle overbearing in their insufferable stubborn
politeness—but in a civilized world you just couldn't turn expectant
mothers out in the rain.
Not even expectant Grdznth mothers.
By the second week the blast was going at full tilt.
In
the Public Relations Bureau building, machines worked on into the
night. As questionnaires came back, spot candid films and street-corner
interview tapes ran through the projectors on a twenty-four-hour
schedule. Tommy Heinz grew thinner and thinner, while Pete nursed sharp
post-prandial stomach pains.
"Why don't people
respond?"
Tommy asked plaintively on the morning the third week started. "Haven't
they got any feelings? The blast is washing over them like a wave and
there they sit!" He punched the private wire to Analysis for the fourth
time that morning. He got a man with a hag-ridden look in his eye. "How
soon?"
"You want yesterday's rushes?"
"What do you think I want? Any sign of a lag?"
"Not a hint. Last night's panel drew like a magnet. The D-Date tag you suggested has them by the nose."
"How about the President's talk?"
The man from Analysis grinned. "He should be campaigning."
Tommy
mopped his forehead with his shirtsleeve. "Okay. Now listen: we need a
special run on all response data we have for tolerance levels. Got that?
How soon can we have it?"
Analysis shook his head. "We could only make a guess with the data so far."
"Fine," said Tommy. "Make a guess."
"Give us three hours," said Analysis.
"You've got thirty minutes. Get going."
Turning
back to Pete, Tommy rubbed his hands eagerly. "It's starting to sell,
boy. I don't know how strong or how good, but it's starting to sell!
With the tolerance levels to tell us how long we can expect this program
to quiet things down, we can give Charlie a deadline to crack his
differential factor, or it's the ax for Charlie." He chuckled to
himself, and paced the room in an overflow of nervous energy. "I can see
it now. Open shafts instead of elevators. A quick hop to Honolulu for
an afternoon on the beach, and back in time for supper. A hundred miles
to the gallon for the Sunday driver. When people begin
seeing
what the Grdznth are giving us, they'll welcome them with open arms."
"Well,
why won't they? The people just didn't trust us, that was all. What
does the man in the street know about transmatters? Nothing. But give
him one, and then try to take it away."
"Sure, sure," said Pete. "It sounds great. Just a little bit
too
great."
Tommy blinked at him. "Too great? Are you crazy?"
"Not crazy. Just getting nervous." Pete jammed his hands into his pockets. "Do you realize where
we're
standing in this thing? We're out on a limb—way out. We're
fighting for time—time for Charlie and his gang to crack the puzzle,
time for the Grdznth girls to gestate. But what are we hearing from
Charlie?"
"Pete, Charlie can't just—"
"That's right," said Pete. "Nothing
is what we're hearing from Charlie. We've got no
transmatter, no null-G, no power, nothing except a whole lot of Grdznth
and more coming through just as fast as they can. I'm beginning to
wonder what the Grdznth
are
giving us."
"Well, they can't gestate forever."
"Maybe
not, but I still have a burning desire to talk to Charlie. Something
tells me they're going to be gestating a little too long."
They
put through the call, but Charlie wasn't answering. "Sorry," the
operator said. "Nobody's gotten through there for three days."
"Three days?" cried Tommy. "What's wrong? Is he dead?"
"Couldn't be. They burned out two more machines yesterday," said the operator. "Killed the switchboard for twenty minutes."
"Get him on the wire," Tommy said. "That's orders."
"Yes, sir. But first they want you in Analysis."
Analysis
was a shambles. Paper and tape piled knee-deep on the floor. The
machines clattered wildly, coughing out reams of paper to be gulped up
by other machines. In a corner office they found the Analysis man, pale
but jubilant.
"The Program," Tommy said. "How's it going?"
"You
can count on the people staying happy for at least another five
months." Analysis hesitated an instant. "If they see some baby Grdznth
at the end of it all."
There was dead silence in the room. "Baby Grdznth," Tommy said finally.
"That's what I said. That's what the people are buying. That's what they'd better get."
Tommy swallowed hard. "And if it happens to be six months?"
Analysis drew a finger across his throat.
Tommy
and Pete looked at each other, and Tommy's hands were shaking. "I
think," he said, "we'd better find Charlie Karns right now."
Math
Section was like a tomb. The machines were silent. In the office at the
end of the room they found an unshaven Charlie gulping a cup of coffee
with a very smug-looking Grdznth. The coffee pot was floating gently
about six feet above the desk. So were the Grdznth and Charlie.
"Charlie!" Tommy howled. "We've been trying to get you for hours! The operator—"
"I know, I know." Charlie waved a hand disjointedly. "I told her to go away. I told the rest of the crew to go away, too."
"Then you cracked the differential?"
Charlie
tipped an imaginary hat toward the Grdznth. "Spike cracked it," he
said. "Spike is a sort of Grdznth genius." He tossed the coffee cup over
his shoulder and it ricochetted in graceful slow motion against the far
wall. "Now why don't you go away, too?"
Tommy
turned purple. "We've got five months," he said hoarsely. "Do you hear
me? If they aren't going to have their babies in five months, we're dead
men."
Charlie
chuckled. "Five months, he says. We figured the babies to come in about
three months—right, Spike? Not that it'll make much difference to us."
Charlie sank slowly down to the desk. He wasn't laughing any more.
"We're never going to see any Grdznth babies. It's going to be a little
too cold for that. The energy factor," he mumbled. "Nobody thought of
that except in passing. Should have, though, long ago. Two completely
independent universes, obviously two energy systems. Incompatible. We
were dealing with mass, space and dimension—but the energy differential
was the important one."
"We're
loaded with it. Super-charged. Packed to the breaking point and way
beyond." Charlie scribbled frantically on the desk pad. "Look, it took
energy for them to come through—immense quantities of energy. Every one
that came through upset the balance, distorted our whole energy pattern.
And they knew from the start that the differential was all on their
side—a million of them unbalances four billion of us. All they needed to
overload us completely was time for enough crossings."
"And
we gave it to them." Pete sat down slowly, his face green. "Like a
rubber ball with a dent in the side. Push in one side, the other side
pops out. And we're the other side. When?"
"Any
day now. Maybe any minute." Charlie spread his hands helplessly. "Oh,
it won't be bad at all. Spike here was telling me. Mean temperature in
only 39 below zero, lots of good clean snow, thousands of nice jagged
mountain peaks. A lovely place, really. Just a little too cold for
Grdznth. They thought Earth was much nicer."
"For them," whispered Tommy.
"For them," Charlie said.
The End